Content Deep Dive

Identity Provider Quirks: How 9 IdPs Bend SAML and OIDC

Blog post from SSOJet

Post Details
Company
Date Published
Author
-
Word Count
2,074
Company Posts That Month
50
Language
English
Hacker News Points
-
Post removed?
No
Summary

Although SAML 2.0 and OpenID Connect are widely supported, identity providers differ substantially in subject identifiers, email and group claims, issuer formats, signature defaults, and SCIM behavior, creating interoperability risks for B2B applications built around one provider’s conventions. The comparison covers Okta, Microsoft Entra ID, Google Workspace, OneLogin, PingOne, JumpCloud, AD FS, Auth0, and Keycloak, highlighting issues such as Entra’s app-specific pairwise subject identifiers and GUID group claims, Google SAML applications’ minimal default attributes, Auth0’s provider-prefixed IDs, and Keycloak’s full-path group values. It recommends storing stable provider-specific identifiers rather than email addresses, configuring attribute and group mappings per customer connection, validating issuers per connection, accepting either properly signed SAML responses or assertions, and enforcing standard token checks such as audience, expiration, nonce, and signatures. To identify incompatibilities before deployment, the post presents SSOJet’s open-source mock-idp tool, which simulates the nine providers’ claim formats and edge cases locally for automated SAML and OIDC testing.

Trends Found in this Post
Trend Post Mentions Total Month Mentions Posts Companies MoM
Platform Engineering 26 2,014 399 102 +19%
Use This Data

Use this post, company, and trend context to find content marketing opportunities, perform competitive analysis, or address product feature gaps via the Plushcap MCP server or the Plushcap API.