Phishing-resistant multifactor authentication (MFA) represents a significant advancement over traditional MFA by providing enhanced security that is immune to phishing attacks, using methods like cryptographic registration and verification. Elastic, a distributed and remote-first organization, recognized the increasing sophistication of phishing attacks and implemented phishing-resistant MFA across its global workforce to protect its assets. This transition involved leveraging Fast Identity Online (FIDO) protocols and focusing on a user-centric approach backed by real-time data insights and automation. The initiative, accomplished in three months, involved extensive employee engagement, executive support, and streamlined communications, significantly reducing the organization's vulnerability to cyber threats. The success story highlights the importance of a scalable, data-driven, and user-focused strategy in effectively addressing modern security challenges.