Dare to test an ugly paywall? Here’s why you should

The concept of an "ugly paywall" challenges conventional design wisdom by prioritizing simplicity and clarity over flashy and complex elements to drive conversions effectively. Despite the initial counterintuitive notion, simplified paywalls, which remove distractions like testimonials, complex animations, and lengthy descriptions, have shown success across both indie and major subscription-based apps. By focusing on clear messaging, straightforward calls to action, and minimalist design, these paywalls reduce decision fatigue and enhance user understanding, potentially leading to higher conversion rates. Notable examples include Strava and Fishbrain, which employ a streamlined paywall structure featuring a bold headline, a few benefit bullet points, and a clear call to action, demonstrating that a minimalist approach can break patterns, capture attention, and aid quick decision-making. Testing these "ugly" paywalls involves setting clear success metrics, running meaningful A/B tests, and iterating based on performance, with potential upsides in revenue and conversion rates outweighing the risks of appearing off-brand or less polished.